Understanding Different Theories of Liability in Personal Injury Cases
by King Law
When you have been injured in an accident and someone else is liable, it is critical to understand the different theories of liability that could apply to your personal injury lawsuit. Some types of personal injury claims can have more than one theory of liability. In such circumstances, your Rochester personal injury attorney can discuss whether you may be able to assert more than one theory of liability in your lawsuit, or whether you will need to select a single theory of liability for moving forward with your claim.
Why is it so important to understand the theory of liability under which you are seeking compensation? The theory of liability will dictate the elements of the claim that you will need to prove in order to win your case. There are several different theories of liability that can be applicable in personal injury lawsuits, and you should always work with a Rochester personal injury lawyer as you determine the particular theory of liability under which the defendant you are suing may be liable.
The theory of liability in a particular case will also be based on the type of personal injury and the specific facts surrounding your case. Generally speaking, personal injury lawsuits tend to fall under one of the following three theories of liability: negligence, strict liability, and breach of warranty. We will provide you with more information about how each of these could be applicable.
Plaintiffs Must Prove That the Defendant Was Negligent in Most Personal Injury Lawsuits
Outside product liability lawsuits and dog bite cases, most personal injury lawsuits will require a plaintiff to prove that the defendant was negligent in order to obtain financial compensation. While the specific elements of each type of personal injury lawsuit based on a theory of negligence will vary depending upon the particular facts, the general elements a plaintiff must prove include:
- Duty of Care: Defendant owed you a duty of care
- Breach: Defendant breached the duty of care by acting negligently
- Causation: Defendant’s breach of the duty of care caused your injuries
- Damages: You suffered an injury resulting in actual damages as a result of the defendant’s breach of the duty of care
Our firm can discuss the ways in which you can prove the defendant’s negligence based on the type of personal injury lawsuit you plan to file and the specific facts surrounding your injury.
Strict Liability Applies Only in Limited Circumstances
In a personal injury case where a plaintiff can file a lawsuit on a theory of strict liability, the plaintiff does not need to prove that the defendant was negligent in any capacity or that the defendant intended to cause harm. Rather, strict liability exists when a defendant is liable for their actions, regardless of their intent or mental state when committing the action that caused harm.
When a plaintiff can argue that the defendant is strictly liable for injuries, this is typically preferable since the plaintiff will not need to show that the defendant was reckless, careless, or otherwise negligent. However, strict liability is used only in a small number of personal injury cases. Generally speaking, you should only expect to be able to bring a strict liability claim for an injury caused by a product defect or from a dog bite involving a dangerous dog.
Understanding Auto Accidents in New York and Insurance Claims
Many personal injury claims are auto insurance claims following a motor vehicle crash in New York. Since New York is a no-fault state, there is no theory of liability when an injured person gets hurt in a car accident and files a first-party claim through their personal injury protection (PIP) coverage. Instead, in a no-fault state like New York, unless a party suffers “serious injuries” as defined by New York law, there is no need to assert a theory of liability or to prove fault since all parties will seek compensation through their own PIP coverage.
Negligence in Car Crashes and Other Personal Injuries
While New York auto insurance claims do not require a theory of liability, car accident cases in which a person sustains a “serious injury” do require a theory of liability if the injured person wants to file a lawsuit. To be clear, you must have a “serious injury” to be eligible to file a car accident lawsuit in New York, and in nearly all cases, the injury victim will argue a theory of negligence.
Negligence is a common theory of liability in many different types of personal injury lawsuits, including but not limited to:
- Motor vehicle collisions involving a “serious injury”
- Boating accidents
- Medical malpractice
- Negligent security
- Slip and fall accidents
- Premises liability lawsuits
- Pedestrian accidents
- Motorcycle accidents
It is critical to determine the precise elements you will need to show in order to prove liability in your case. Generally speaking, however, most negligence claims require a plaintiff to prove the following:
- Defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care
- Defendant breached the duty of care by being negligent (which often includes any careless act or failure to act that would be unreasonable to a reasonable person)
- Plaintiff suffered an injury
- Plaintiff has damages
Understanding Other Types of Liability
Depending on the type of injury you are experiencing, there are different types of liability. For example, injuries from asbestos-based products and injuries from defective products involve exploring how companies that make products might be liable for harms caused.
Product Liability in Asbestos Cases
Companies that made asbestos products or manufactured and transported asbestos have been named in thousands of product liability lawsuits. Asbestos companies had information that asbestos was dangerous to human health and carcinogenic. Many of these companies concealed the dangers of their products or did not issue proper warnings to businesses and consumers. They had a duty to warn people about the safety of their products and did not do so. Thus, they are found legally liable and negligent for the harms their products caused. Asbestos companies are named as defendants in mesothelioma lawsuits and ordered to pay damages to the people whom they harmed.
Breach of Warranty in Product Liability Lawsuits
Some product liability lawsuits can involve a theory of breach of warranty. You should discuss this option with your personal injury lawyer if you were injured after using a defective consumer product. You may be eligible to file a mass tort claim.
Contact Our Rochester Personal Injury Lawyers
Determining the theory of liability under which to build your personal injury lawsuit can be extremely complicated, but one of the experienced Rochester personal injury attorneys at our firm can assess the facts of your case today and help you develop a strong claim. We are committed to providing tailored and experienced representation to every personal injury plaintiff, and to working together with injured plaintiffs to build strong and compelling cases for financial compensation. Contact King Law today to get started on your claim with one of our personal injury lawyers in Rochester.
Categories