Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit – January 2025 Update

The Earth's Best Baby Food Lawsuit Is An Active Lawsuit

See If You Qualify!

Hain Celestial Group, Inc., the manufacturer of Earth’s Best baby foods, is facing lawsuits from parents who allege the company knowingly made and sold baby foods that contained high levels of heavy metals. The lawsuits allege the heavy metals present in Earth’s Best baby foods led to children developing autism spectrum disorder and other developmental disorders. A growing number of studies have found that babies and young children exposed to heavy metals are at an increased risk of developmental delays and cognitive disorders. Many parents have filed lawsuits against Hain Celestial Group as part of multidistrict litigation (MDL) #3101 – In Re: Baby Food Products Liability Litigation. The number of lawsuits against Hain Celestial Group and other baby food manufacturers is expected to grow significantly over the coming months, as more parents seek compensation for their children’s injuries. 

Earth’s Best Lawsuit 2025 Updates

January 8, 2025: FDA Issues More Guidance on Lead Levels Manufacturers Should Allow in Baby Foods

The FDA issued new guidance that is intended to decrease the amount of lead found in Earth’s Best baby foods made by Hain and foods made by other manufacturers. The updated industry guidance sets what lead levels should be found in different types of baby foods and foods for children under two. These updates to action levels for lead in baby food were issued on January 7, 2025. The updated levels are: 10 parts per billion (ppb) for fruits, most vegetables, mixed purees, yogurts, puddings, and single-ingredient meats; 20 ppb for single-ingredient root vegetables; and 20 ppb for dry infant cereals. As these levels are all voluntary, child-heath advocates worry about the effectiveness of this FDA action. Children will likely continue to be exposed to lead, which can cause autism and other development issues. Parents will continue to file lawsuits to hold manufacturers accountable and seek justice for their children.

January 3, 2025: More Parents File Baby Food Lawsuits against Hain Celestial Group and Other Manufacturers

During the month of December 2024, 13 new plaintiffs joined the consolidated lawsuit against Hain Celestial Group and other baby food manufacturers. As more parents realize that high levels of toxic metals in Earth’s Best baby foods might have led to their children developing autism, the federal litigation is likely to grow. These lawsuits look to hold Hain Celestial Group and other baby food manufacturers accountable for knowingly producing foods with high levels of heavy metals, which have likely harmed babies and children.

December 20, 2024: MDL Grows to 75 Pending Cases

More parents are filing lawsuits against Hain Celestial Group and other baby food manufacturers. MDL#: 3101 – In Re: Baby Food Products Liability Litigation has grown to 75 pending cases, representing a 44% increase since November. The number of cases is expected to continue to grow, considering the widespread use of baby food products such as Earth’s Best.

November 5, 2024: Joint Statement Filed for November 7 Case Management Conference

More progress is being made in the federal lawsuit against Hain Celestial Group and other baby food manufacturers. A joint statement has been filed in the baby food products liability MDL filed out of the Northern District of California. The statement, filed with the court on November 5, indicated that plaintiffs had received proof of service on all defendants except one and would be filing a “Notice of Completed Service” at the case management conference. Preservation statements and schedules on general causation were also set.

May 23, 2024: Rudy’s Law Passed in Maryland

Rudy’s Law has been passed in Maryland. The law requires baby food manufacturers to test their products monthly beginning January 1, 2025, and make information, including test results, available to the public beginning January 1, 2026. Additional states are expected to follow suit in the following months and years. California passed a similar bill in October 2023. 

May 9, 2024: Sen. Klobuchar Introduces Baby Food Safety Act of 2024

Senator Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) introduced the Baby Food Safety Act of 2024 on May 9, 2024. If passed, the bill would establish limits on the amount of heavy metals (e.g., arsenic, lead, cadmium, and mercury) in infant and toddler foods in the United States. The bill would also require baby food manufacturers to routinely test their products and keep detailed records of the results.

April 11, 2024: JPML Agrees to Consolidate Cases in Baby Food Product Liability Cases

The Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation agreed to consolidate multiple lawsuits into multidistrict litigation out of the Northern District of California after hearing arguments on the matter. The MDL is (MDL) #3101 – In Re: Baby Food Products Liability Litigation. The court found that the plaintiffs, who are mostly parents of children of children with developmental disorders, had common questions of facts and common issues in support of centralization. One of the defendants named in the MDL is Hain Celestial Group, Inc., the manufacturer of Earth’s Best baby food products.

About the Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit:

Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit Overview

Parents and other concerned parties are filing lawsuits against Hain Celestial Group, Inc., which makes Earth’s Best baby and toddler food. Internal and independent testing of Earth’s Best baby foods have shown that many of its products contain concerning levels of heavy metals, such as arsenic, lead, cadmium, and mercury.  Research suggests that high levels of heavy metals in baby food products may lead to children developing autism spectrum disorder and other neurodevelopmental disorders.  

Legal documents allege that Hain Celestial Group knew its products contained dangerous levels of heavy metals and failed to warn consumers about the potential for harm associated with consuming these products.  

As these lawsuits continue to be filed, many parents are asking how to best protect their children. Parents should remain vigilant, researching baby food products and levels of heavy metals detected by internal or third-party testing. Furthermore, parents of children diagnosed with autism after consuming Earth’s Best baby food are encouraged to contact an attorney experienced in product liability litigation.

2021 Congressional Report: Earth’s Best Baby Food Findings and Insights

Hain Celestial Group, Inc., which sells products under the name Earth’s Best Organic, provided internal data on testing their heavy metal products. The House of Representatives Subcommittee on Economic and Consumer Policy Committee on Oversight and Reform requested the information after allegations that commercial baby food products contained high levels of toxic heavy metals. The results were published in a 2021 Congressional report.

Findings from the 2021 Congressional Report:

• Arsenic: Hain Celestial Group sold baby products containing inorganic arsenic levels as high as 129 parts per billion (ppb). The company failed to test finished products, only sampling raw ingredients. Furthermore, data showed the company used ingredients with arsenic levels as high as 309 ppb.
• Lead: Earth’s Best Organic ingredients contain lead levels as high as 352 ppb. Dozens of ingredients had lead levels exceeding 20 ppb, and six had lead levels over 200 ppb.
• Cadmium: More 100 ingredients were used in Earth’s Best Organic products with cadmium levels over 20 ppb. In some instances, ingredients contained cadmium levels up to 260 ppb.
• Mercury: Hain did not test its Earth’s Best Organic products for mercury despite its toxicity. 

Exposure to toxic heavy metals can have devastating effects on the developing brain, including increasing the risk of developing autism spectrum disorder. Parents of children diagnosed with autism prior to age 14 are encouraged to contact an attorney to discuss their legal options.

Toxic Metals Found in Earth’s Best Baby Foods

Testing of Earth’s Best Organic products determined the presence of concerning levels of heavy metals, such as arsenic, lead, cadmium, and mercury. These metals can be especially toxic to developing brains and when consumed by young children and infants. These metals are present in baby foods due to a number of mechanism. One example is some plants absorb metals as a result of contaminated soil and water, and some plants are more likely to absorb these metals than other plants. However, little has been done to reduce or eliminate the metals in baby food products before those products reach the market. 

Heavy Metals Identified in Earth’s Best Organic Baby Foods:

• Arsenic
• Lead
• Cadmium
• Mercury

The manufacturer of Earth’s Best has acknowledged the presence of heavy metals in their products and claims to have implemented measures to help minimize the level in its ingredients or final products.

Arsenic

Consumption of arsenic can negatively impact a child’s development. Studies show exposure to arsenic may cause cancer and be linked to an increased risk of autism and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). 

Ingredients most at risk for high arsenic levels:

• Rice and rice-based products
• Apple and grape juices
• Products containing root vegetables. 

According to the 2019 Healthy Babies Bright Futures study, arsenic was detected in 73% of baby food tested. Rice-based products were the most susceptible to high levels of arsenic. A 2023 Consumer Reports study determined that some arsenic levels improved, but the concern was not eliminated.  

Lead

Lead poisoning is a serious concern for parents. Exposure to the heavy metal can have adverse health effects. The 2019 Healthy Babies Bright Futures found that 94% of baby foods tested had lead in them. The 2021 Congressional report found that Hain Celestial Group, the manufacturer of Earth’s Best Organic, routinely used ingredients with high levels of lead, well beyond the 10 ppb action level proposed by the FDA. 

Products with the highest level of lead:

• Apple juice
• Grape juice
• Carrots
• Sweet potatoes
• Other foods containing root vegetables
• Rice-based products
• Teething biscuits

Cadmium

Exposure to cadmium can cause significant health concerns, especially in babies and young children. The 2019 Healthy Babies Bright Futures study detected cadmium in 75% of the baby food products they tested. Astonishingly, very few state or federal standards exist to regulate the level of cadmium in baby food that makes it to market in the U.S. 

Baby food products with potentially high levels of cadmium:

• Carrots
• Sweet potatoes
• Rice and rice-based products
• Spinach
• Leafy greens
• Rice snacks

Mercury

Despite its toxicity, most baby food manufacturers, including Hain, do not test their raw ingredients or finished products for mercury. The 2019 Healthy Babies Bright Futures study found that 32% of the baby food tested contained mercury. 

Baby food products containing potentially harmful levels of mercury:

• Rice and rice-based products
• Fish-based products
• Apple and grape juices
• Carrots 
• Sweet potatoes
• Products with other root vegetables

Earth’s Best Baby Food Products With Heavy Metals

Several Earth’s Best Organic products contain heavy metals, such as arsenic, lead, cadmium, and mercury. Concerningly, many of the products contained multiple heavy metals. While the FDA set recommendations for arsenic levels of 100 ppb, Hain increased their internal limits to 200 ppb. However, even after setting these higher limits for heavy metals, Hain continued to release products exceeding their own standards. 

Earth’s Best Baby Food with Heavy Metals as Reported by Motherhood Community and Healthy Babies Bright Futures Study:

Arsenic:

• Raw ingredients: Contained arsenic levels up to 309 ppb
• Finished baby food products: Contained arsenic levels up to 129 ppb
  • Whole Grain Rice Cereal: 138 ppb
  • Whole Grain Oatmeal Cereal: 29.5 ppb

Lead:

• Raw ingredients: Contained lead levels up to 352 ppb
  • Product of specific concern: Sweet potatoes 

Cadmium:

• Raw ingredients: Contained cadmium levels up to 260 ppb
  • Product of specific concern: Carrots

Mercury:

• The company did not test its raw ingredients or finished products for mercury.

Earth’s Best and Hain Baby Cereal Lawsuits

Many of the Earth’s Best products that had high levels of heavy metals were infant and baby cereals. Earth’s Best oatmeal cereals and rice cereals were found to have high levels of arsenic. According to the 2021 congressional report, half of its brown rice baby foods contained more than 100 ppb
inorganic arsenic. For comparison, the FDA limit for inorganic arsenic in bottled water is 10 ppb. These high levels of arsenic have led many parents to file lawsuits against Hain Celestial Group.

Studies Linking Autism to Baby Food Consumption

Several studies have linked consuming baby food contaminated with toxic heavy metals to an increased risk of developing autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Infants and young children are particularly susceptible to heavy metal toxicity due to their developing brains and bodies. 

Association Between Heavy Metals Exposure and Child Autistic Disorder

A July 2023 study published in Frontiers in Pediatrics authored by Mengmeng Ding, Shanshan Shi, Shuyan Qie, Jinglu Li, and Xiaoming Xi investigated the connection between heavy metal exposure and ASD. The study was called, “Association between heavy metals exposure (cadmium, lead, arsenic, mercury) and child autistic disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis.”

The research concluded that children with autism had higher concentrations of cadmium, lead, arsenic, and mercury compared to the control group (children without an autism diagnosis). These findings suggest a strong association between heavy metal exposure and autism in children and babies. There were also regional variations likely due to contaminated soil and water in those areas. The study highlights the need for additional research to raise awareness and understanding of the problem.

Investigating the Role of Food Pollutants in Autism Spectrum Disorder

A study published on October 28, 2024, in Naunyn-Schmiedeberg’s Archives of Pharmacology, sought to explore the link between pollutants in foods and the development of autism in children and babies. The study, called: “Investigating the role of food pollutants in autism spectrum disorder: a comprehensive analysis of heavy metals, pesticides, and mycotoxins” found elevated levels of lead, mercury, and cadmium in individuals with ASD. 

Toxic Heavy Metal Content of Infant and Toddler Foods and Evaluation of United States Policy

A June 2022 Narrative Review in Frontiers in Nutrition by Emily C. Bair reviewed studies published between January 1999 and April 2022 to evaluate policies in the United States to mitigate exposure. The research concluded there was a need for stricter policies, oversight, and regulation related to commercial baby and toddler food nationwide. 

Association of Autism With Toxic Metals

A study published in 2021 in Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior sought to evaluate the relationship between exposure to heavy metals and autism spectrum disorder. The study, authored by Cecilia N. Amadi, Chinna N. Orish, Chiara Frazzoli, and Orish E. Orisakwe, reviewed case-control studies and determined that elevated toxic metal levels were associated with ASD. Furthermore, the authors recommended reducing heavy metal exposure in children with ASD as a potential therapeutic strategy.

Earth’s Best’s Response to Toxic Metal Allegations in Baby Food

According to the manufacturer’s website, Earth’s Best Organic acknowledges the presence of heavy metals in their products but says that they follow applicable FDA and Department of Agriculture recommendations to screen raw materials and finished products. The company also states that they continually develop and adhere to new safety standards and practices.

Furthermore, Hain Celestial Group, the manufacturer of Earth’s Best, responded to requests by the Subcommittee on Economic and Consumer Policy Committee on Oversight and Reform for internal testing data. However, the company continues to face legal challenges regarding the level of heavy metals in its baby food products, as many of their products still contain high levels of heavy metals.

Federal Government’s Initiatives to Eliminate Heavy Metals in Baby Food

After growing concerns about a potential link between heavy metals and autism spectrum disorder, state and federal governments have launched initiatives to reduce contamination of the substances in baby food products. 

Initiatives to eliminate heavy metals in baby food products in the U.S.:

• Baby Food Safety Act of 2024: Introduced by Senator Amy Klobuchar on May 9, 2024. If passed, it would establish limits on heavy metals in baby and toddler food in the U.S. It would also require regular testing and record keeping for heavy metal levels in products manufactured in the U.S. and abroad.
• FDA’s Closer to Zero Initiative: Launched in 2021 in response to growing concerns over the level and potential harm of heavy metals in baby foods. Sets target dates to issue final guidance on limits and offer best practices for manufacturers.
• California Assembly Bill 899 (AB-899): Signed into law on October 10, 2023, by Governor Gavin Newsom. The law requires baby food manufacturers to test their products monthly beginning January 1, 2025, and to make results available online.

Eligibility Criteria for the Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit

In order to file a lawsuit against Earth’s Best Organics, individuals must meet certain eligibility requirements. In general, children must have been born on or after January 1, 2007, and have received an autism diagnosis before age 14. 

Eligibility criteria for an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit:

• Age: Child must have been born on or after January 1, 2007.
• Autism Diagnosis: Child must have been diagnosed with autism before age 14.
• Proof of Purchase: Child must have consumed eligible baby food products for at least six months.

Who Would Be Excluded From the Earth’s Best Lawsuit?

While many children who have been diagnosed with autism after consuming Earth’s Best baby food will qualify for a lawsuit, there are some exclusions. It is essential to discuss your case with an experienced attorney to determine if your child meets the eligibility requirements necessary to take legal action.

Potential exclusions from an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit:

• Preterm birth (born prior to 37 weeks)
• Low birth weight (under 5.5. pounds at birth)
• Autism diagnosis after the age of 14
• Consumed baby food products for less than six months
• Diagnosed with a disqualifying syndrome or condition
• Participation in related litigation
• Advanced maternal age at conception
• Some maternal health or pregnancy complications

Evidence Needed to File an Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit

Substantial evidence is often needed to prove an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit. The best way to determine what evidence may be needed to support your claim is by consulting with an attorney well-versed in toxic exposure and product liability cases. 

Evidence needed to file an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit may include:

• Mental health records
• Neurodevelopmental assessments
• Medical records
• Proof of autism diagnosis
• Proof of purchase of Earth’s Best Organics baby food
• Bank statements and receipts
• Loyalty program records
• Witness statements
• Personal account
• Product labels and marketing materials
• Hair follicle or blood sampling for heavy metals
• Food diaries and growth charts
• Family or genetic history records

What Damages Can I Recover in the Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit?

Recoverable damages in an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit may include coverage for economic and non-economic losses. Compensation often covers medical costs, expenses related to treatment or therapy, support for educational services, emotional distress, and loss of quality of life. Parents may be eligible for compensation related to lost wages, needed modifications to the home, assistive devices, and wrongful death damages, if applicable. 

In some circumstances, the court may award additional penalties, including attorney’s fees, court costs, allocations for a special needs trust, and even punitive damages.

How to File an Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit

There are several steps to filing an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit. Foremost, you need to speak with an experienced attorney. An attorney can help determine whether you meet the eligibility criteria necessary to file a claim and will help you navigate the legal process. 

Steps to file an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit:

1. Consult with a toxic exposure lawyer: The first step in an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit is to consult with an experienced toxic exposure lawyer. A lawyer can help determine whether you meet the eligibility requirements necessary to take legal action.
2. Gather evidence: Next, you will need to gather the evidence necessary to support your claim. This evidence may include your child’s medical records, any neurodevelopmental assessments, proof of purchase of qualifying baby food products, and documents showing you experienced actual losses related to the injury.
3. File the claim: Once the evidence has been gathered, your attorney will file a claim in the appropriate venue. Before filing, your attorney will make sure that all legal requirements are met, including that the case is filed within the state-specific statute of limitations.

Earth’s Best Baby Food Settlement and Payout Amounts

While the Earth’s Best baby food lawsuits are still in their early stages, estimated settlements are expected to range between $500,000 and $1.5 million. The payout will largely depend on the facts of the case, including the severity of the injury or autism diagnosis. It is imperative to speak with an experienced attorney to obtain case-specific estimates about the potential value of your case.

Statute of Limitations to File an Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawsuit

The statute of limitations in an Earth’s Best baby food lawsuit is state-specific and generally ranges between 1 and 6 years. Several factors may affect the amount of time you have to file a lawsuit, including the date of the autism diagnosis and the discovery of the link between contaminated baby food and autism. It is critical to consult with an attorney as early in the process as possible to ensure timely filing of your claim.

Contact an Earth’s Best Baby Food Lawyer

If your child was diagnosed with autism before the age of 14 and consumed Earth’s Best baby food products for at least six months, you may be eligible to file a lawsuit. King Law is well-versed in product liability and toxic exposure claims. We will work with you to gather needed evidence and determine the best course of action for your case. We will work diligently to get you and your family the best possible outcome from your lawsuit. Contact us discuss eligibility and your legal options.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)